MarketWatch
Social Security says I was overpaid for 7 years. I believe it’s mistaken. Can they cut my benefits?
Saturday, June 27, 2026
Title: Social Security Overpayment Dispute: Beneficiary Questions Agency's Earnings Records
A Social Security beneficiary disputes the agency's determination that they were overpaid benefits over a seven-year period, stating that the agency misidentified the year in which they earned $43,000. The beneficiary reported earning the amount in 2020, while Social Security's records indicate it was earned in 2019. Social Security can adjust or reduce future benefits to recover overpayments, though beneficiaries have the right to appeal determinations they believe are incorrect. The case raises questions about how earnings records are verified and corrected in the Social Security system.